2005 Natalie Wood

2006 Kasey Wilder

2007 Jasmine Murray | Top Ten

2008 Morgan Lindsey Burnett

2009 Laura Lee Lewis

2010 Christina Bostick

2011 France Beard

2012 Molly May | 4th alternate to Miss America's Teen and Preliminary Talent Winner

2013 Anne Elizabeth Buys

2014 Grace Munro

2015 Grace Post

2016 Stella Ford

2017 Holly Brand

2018 Presley Caldwell

2019 Jane Granberry | Top Ten

2021 Tori Johnston | Top Ten

2022 Cameron Davis

2023 | Nataleigh Nix

2024 Brooke Bumgarner | 2nd Alternate Miss America's Teen

2025 Avery McNair | Evening Gown Preliminary Award

2027 Madalyn Sullivan {Oxford}